Cryptic Species and Synonyms

The Objective : Populations of Spurilla neapolitana and S. sargassicola in the tropical Eastern Pacific and Western Atlantic are assessed through genetic and morphological analyses of specimens to determine whether any cryptic species of S. neapolitana exist and conclude whether S. sargassicola is a synonym of S. neapolitana.

Methods/Materials

S. neapolitana specimens from 5 Pacific locations and 2 Atlantic ones were compared with S. sargassicola specimens. Partial 16S rRNA and H3 histone coding genes were extracted from non-cerata tissue using Chelex, then amplified in PCR.

Cleaned and diluted PCR products were sequenced then analyzed using computer programs Geneious, CLC Free Workbench, and MacClade. Diagnostically reliable features including the radulae, jaws, reproductive organs, and external morphology were compared through the use of SEM micrographs and camera lucida.

Results

Maximum likelihood trees (1000 bootstrap replicates) constructed from 16S and H3 sequences both demonstrate that the Stocking Island, Bahamas population of S. neapolitana is an exclusive clade. 16S tree shows that S. sargassicola groups with all other S. neapolitana specimens.

Morphological data corroborates these findings. The Bahamas S. neapolitana population has significantly (P=0.01) longer and slimmer lateral denticles and central cusps in the radula than all other specimens.

The convoluted bursa copulatrix structure of the reproductive system was also identical for all Atlantic specimens, except Bahamas S. neapolitana. The jaws and external morphology are proven to be inefficacious as differentiating characteristics.

Conclusions/Discussion

With the presented data it is certain that S. sargassicola is a synonym of S. neapolitana and should not retain its separate species name. Also, the Bahamas population of S. neapolitana is identified as a highly likely cryptic species which will be verified once fresh specimens of other Spurilla species are obtained to serve as accurate outgroups. These results provide crucial insight into the understanding of biodiversity in this genus and thus are key to future conservation efforts.

Genetic and morphological analyses are utilized to determine whether any cryptic species of circumtropical aeolid Spurilla neapolitana exist and conclude whether similar species S. sargassicola is a synonym of S. neapolitana.

Science Fair Project done By Bonnie R. Lei

 

 

<<Back To Topics Page...................................................................................>>Next Topic

Related Projects : Chemical Basis for Ant Behavior ,Chicken Eggshell Strength ,Correlation of Owl Limpet Size to Population Density ,Creepy Crawlies: Exposed ,Crustacean Location ,Cryptic Species and Synonyms ,Dialoguing with Dolphins ,Did You Bite Off More Than You Can Chew ,Do Goldfish Respond to Certain Conditioned Stimuli ,Do Horses Respond to Human Emotion