Effect of Mascara on Contact Lens Disinfection

The Objective : To determine if contact lens disinfecting solutions will work as well if mascara comes in contact with the solutions during use. To evaluate the activities of three different disinfecting solutions against two bacterial skin isolates in the presence of two different mascara products.

Methods/Materials

For each solution and mascara, two different bacteria were spread onto the surfaces of separate agar plates.

Metal penicylinders were then placed on the plates and were filled with either contact lens disinfecting solution, contact lens disinfecting solution containing 0.1 mg/mL mascara or 0.1 mg/mL mascara (control).

Plates were incubated until bacterial lawns were formed. Clearing around the penicylinders indicated that disinfecting solutions prevented growth.

The clearing produced circular zones which could then be measured.

Results for disinfecting solutions with and without mascara could then be compared to each other and to results for mascara alone.

Results

Test results indicated that both mascaras decreased the activities of the disinfecting solutions that contained either 0.0001% polyhexamethylene biguanide or 0.001% polyquaternium-1 and 0.0005% myristaidiopropyl dimethylamine.

Test results indicated that both mascaras did not have an effect on the disinfecting solution containing 3% hydrogen peroxide.

Differences could be seen among the disinfecting solutions and differences were seen when testing the 2 bacteria. The hydrogen peroxide disinfecting solution displayed the greatest amount of activity against both bacteria.

Conclusions/Discussion

Mascara can adversely affect some contact lens disinfecting solutions. Therefore, users should take special care to rub and rinse their lenses to remove any traces of mascara.

This project examines the effect of mascara on contact lens disinfection.

Science Fair Project done By Ariana N. Rupp

 

 

<<Back To Topics Page...................................................................................>>Next Topic

Related Projects : Catchers Are Protected Behind Home Plate ,Comparing the Effectiveness of Toothpaste Brands on Minimizing Tooth Decay ,Comparing the Results of Blood Glucose Meters ,Determining The Combustibility of Household Paints ,Do Debbie Meyer Green Bags Really Work to Preserve Fruits and Vegetables ,Does the Fat Content in Dairy Affect Its Taste ,Ear Protection and Noise-Induced Hearing Loss ,Economic Generic Brands vs. Name Brand Sunscreen ,Effect of Light Bulb Type on Energy Consumption ,Effect of Mascara on Contact Lens Disinfection